When you’re heading deep into the wild, every piece of gear counts. You don’t want extra weight, but you also don’t want to miss something that could make life easier—or even save the day.
That’s where the “Backpacking Knife” vs. “Multi-Tool” debate comes in.
Many outdoor lovers wonder which tool makes more sense to carry. To help you make an informed decision, we are going to break down both options in the simplest way possible.
You’ll learn how each tool works, what it’s good for, and which one might suit your trip best.
Let’s get into it.
What’s the Real Difference Between Them
• A backpacking knife is a single, fixed, or folding blade made to cut. It’s simple, sharp, and strong. You use it to slice rope, prep food, whittle wood, or even open cans if you need to. It’s usually lightweight and easy to pack.
• A multi-tool, on the other hand, is like a small toolbox in your pocket. It has several fold-out tools such as small knives, pliers, screwdrivers, scissors, and maybe even a can opener. It’s made for people who want to be ready for anything.
Both are helpful, but they do different jobs.
When a Backpacking Knife Makes More Sense
If you're planning on spending most of your trip hiking, setting up camp, and cooking over an open flame, then this knife is a better option.
Here's why:
• Simplicity, for real: A good knife just gets the job done quicker - no fiddling around with multiple pieces or awkwardly flipping mechanisms.
• Strength is key: The blade on a knife is usually stronger and a bit longer than what you'd find on a multi-tool.
• Food prep is a breeze: Slicing up meat, fruit, and veg is a heck of a lot easier with a bigger blade.
• Wood tasks are a snap: Need to make some fire sticks, cut some rope, or shave up some kindling? A solid knife will have it done in no time.
In short, one good blade will cover a lot if you're not expecting to do any repairs or fancy technical stuff.
Why Some Hikers Pick a Multi-Tool
Some hikers really like using a multi-tool because it has many built-in tools. Here’s when it comes in handy:
• Fixing gear: You can repair a bent tent pole, tighten a loose screw, or use the pliers to cut wire.
• Small emergencies: It’s helpful for things like pulling out splinters, bending metal, or making quick fixes on the trail.
• Town stops: If your hike goes through towns or mixed areas, a multi-tool can be useful for more than just the outdoors.
• Saves space: You get several tools in one, so it can take up less room in your pack.
But remember, multi-tools are usually heavier, and their knives aren’t always strong enough for tough outdoor tasks.
Backpacking Knife vs. Multi-Tool: What Really Matters?
When choosing between these two options, it’s important to think about what you’ll actually be doing on your trip.
Ask yourself:
• Will I need to build campfires or prepare fresh food?
• Do I need tools to fix my gear?
• Is it more important to save space or have more features?
• How much weight am I okay with carrying?
If your trip is more focused on survival or you're heading far off the trail, a backpacking knife might be the better choice. But if you want more tools in one and extra versatility, the multi-tool could be the way to go.
Other Things to Consider
Weight and Space: Do They Really Matter?
Yes, especially when you're hiking long distances.
A backpacking knife usually weighs less than a multi-tool. It also takes up less space. That might not sound like a big deal, but over time, every ounce adds up. If you're cutting back on gear, that saved weight can mean faster miles and less stress on your body.
Still, if you rely on certain features like screwdrivers or pliers, the extra weight of a multi-tool might be worth it. The key is knowing your trip needs before you pack.
Safety and Ease of Use
• A backpacking knife—whether it’s a fixed blade or a folding one—is usually easier and safer for cutting. You just take it out and use it. No need to mess with extra parts.
• A multi-tool takes more time to open and can be harder to use, especially in cold weather or with gloves on. Some tools can even pinch your hand if you use them for too long.
So, while a multi-tool gives you more options, it’s not always the most comfortable choice. If your main priorities are speed, comfort, and strong cutting power, the backpacking one is still the top pick.
What About Carrying Both?
Absolutely. Even some experienced hikers do just that.
They bring a strong, lightweight backpacking knife for things like cooking, cutting rope, or other camp tasks, and also carry a small multi-tool for quick fixes and small repairs.
You don’t have to pick just one. If you have the space and the extra weight isn’t a problem, carrying both can be a smart move.
Just make sure both tools are good quality and easy to grab when you need them. Carrying both only makes sense if you’re actually going to use them. Otherwise, it’s just extra weight.
Final Thoughts
In the end, the choice between a backpacking knife and a multi-tool depends on your trip style. If you need a tool that’s strong, sharp, and simple, the knife wins. If you want one item that does a little bit of everything, the multi-tool is your answer.
Remember: It’s not about carrying the most stuff but the right one.
Think through your trip, your tasks, and your gear needs before making the call. No matter which one you choose, make sure it’s well-made and ready for the trail ahead.
Want a knife or tool built for real outdoor adventures? Check out premium options at Terrain 365. Shop now.